• Hidden Alpha
  • Posts
  • A Decade-Long Quest: The Historic Approval of the First US Spot Bitcoin ETF

A Decade-Long Quest: The Historic Approval of the First US Spot Bitcoin ETF

The Dawn of a New Era Where Institutions Can Acquire Bitcoin Spot

After an extensive ten-year journey, the financial landscape was marked by a groundbreaking development as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued a landmark decision, greenlighting the first regulated spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) in the United States.

This approval represented a significant triumph for the cryptocurrency sector, cementing its evolving relationship with mainstream finance.

Origins of Innovation: The Winklevoss ETF Application

The saga began on July 1, 2013, when Gemini co-founders and tech entrepreneurs Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss laid the groundwork for crypto-ETFs by filing the inaugural application for a spot Bitcoin ETF in the U.S. The proposal generated buzz and brought forth discussions about the integration of cryptocurrencies into the traditional financial system.

However, momentum stumbled as the SEC ultimately dismissed the application in 2017, casting doubts among finance experts and media observers about Bitcoin's readiness for mass-market adoption.

A Nascent Alternative: The Emergence of Grayscale Bitcoin Trust

Parallel to the quest for approval, in 2013, Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) entered the scene as an open-ended, private trust, targeting accredited investors. It marked a significant yet interim solution by receiving the nod from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) to trade publicly two years later in 2015. Although GBTC was not an ETF, it became the first Bitcoin fund trading on the U.S. market and set the stage for a future conversion into a spot-based ETF.

Persistence Meets Resistance: Continued SEC Setbacks

Undeterred by the previous denial, the Winklevoss twins reignited their efforts for a spot Bitcoin ETF, which faced another SEC blockade in 2018. The commission cited the predominantly unregulated nature of Bitcoin as the core reason for its refusal, further postponing the crypto community's long-held aspirations.

International Progress: Canada Leads the Way

The pursuit of a Bitcoin spot ETF saw glimmers of hope as Canada emerged as a pioneer. In 2021, Fidelity Canada launched its own spot Bitcoin ETF, setting a precedent as the largest asset manager to do so at the time.

The move, highlighted by ETF analyst Eric Balchunas, suggested an international trend that might influence the US regulatory stance.

The Final Stretch: Rejections, Lawsuits, and Ultimate Victory

Despite the Canadian breakthrough, 2022 was rife with disappointments as the SEC continued to deny multiple spot Bitcoin ETF applications from prominent asset managers such as SkyBridge, Fidelity, Bitwise, and Grayscale.

In a bold response to this string of rejections, Grayscale Investments took the legal route and filed a lawsuit against the SEC, following the knock-back on converting GBTC into a spot-based ETF.

A New Chapter for Crypto: Spot Bitcoin ETF Becomes Reality

Finally, after years of regulatory hurdles, the tireless work of advocates, and mounting pressure from a swiftly evolving global financial landscape, the SEC’s nod to a spot Bitcoin ETF in the U.S. has unleashed a wave of optimism. The decision marks a pivotal shift in the intersection of digital assets and regulated financial markets, paving the way for broader acceptance and integration of cryptocurrencies into traditional investment portfolios. The crypto industry, at last, celebrates the culmination of its decade-long journey toward achieving this historic regulatory milestone.